When you’re faced with the difficult decision to rehome a pet, it’s natural to want to find them a new home as quickly as possible. Many well-meaning pet owners turn to online classifieds or community groups with a “Free to Good Home” ad, hoping a kind person will give their beloved animal a safe and loving new life. But offering a pet for free—even with good intentions—can lead to heartbreaking and dangerous consequences.
Here’s why giving a pet away for free is risky, and what you can do instead.
1. Free Pets Attract the Wrong People
Unfortunately, not everyone who responds to a free pet ad has good intentions. Free pets are frequently targeted by:
- Reptile feeders: Small pets like rabbits, guinea pigs, hamsters, rats, and even kittens have been taken under the guise of being adopted—only to be fed live or dead to large reptiles. This is more common than many realize and is a horrifying end for animals given away without safeguards.
- Animal abusers: People looking for animals to harm, either for “fun,” cruel training purposes, or rituals, may browse “free pet” listings.
- Dogfighters: In dogfighting circles, free pets are sometimes taken and used as “bait animals” to train aggressive dogs.
- Flippers: Some people take free pets with the intention of reselling them for a profit, often without any concern for their wellbeing.
- Backyard breeders: Unfixed pets may be used for unregulated, high-risk breeding operations in poor conditions.
2. No-Cost Means Less Commitment
When someone pays an adoption fee—even a modest one—they’re making an investment and are more likely to value the animal and its care. A free pet can be seen as disposable. If problems arise, that person may be more likely to abandon or surrender the animal to a shelter.
3. No Way to Screen for Safety
When you offer a pet for free, you often don’t take time to screen potential adopters. Without an application process, reference checks, or even a home visit, you have no way of knowing:
- If the person has the time, resources, and experience to care for the pet
- If they have other animals and whether those pets are safe and healthy
- If their living environment is appropriate (safe housing, pet-friendly, etc.)
4. You Could Be Held Responsible
In some cases, if a pet ends up neglected, injured, or causing harm, the original owner may face emotional consequences—or even legal repercussions—depending on the situation.
5. Shelters and Rescues Are Overwhelmed
You may think you’re helping the shelter system by rehoming your pet yourself—but when a free pet is later abandoned, surrendered, or found as a stray, the burden still falls on rescues and animal control. Worse, those animals may not get a second chance.
Safer Alternatives to Giving a Pet Away for Free
If you truly need to rehome your pet, here are responsible steps to take:
- Ask for an adoption fee: This discourages people with bad intentions and signals that the animal is valuable.
- Use a pet adoption application: Ask about the potential adopter’s experience, lifestyle, and home situation.
- Ask for references: Vet references, personal references, and even a landlord check (if applicable) can provide peace of mind.
- Meet in person: Ideally, visit the home or meet in a neutral place to observe the adopter and their interactions with your pet.
- Work with a rescue: Many rescues offer “courtesy posts” or rehoming help, even if you don’t want to surrender your pet.
- Spay/neuter and vaccinate first: This prevents your pet from being used for breeding and helps ensure their future health.
Your Pet Deserves a Safe Future
Rehoming a pet is never easy, but taking the time to do it safely is an act of love. By avoiding “free to good home” ads and putting safeguards in place, you help ensure your pet gets the second chance they truly deserve—with a family ready to commit for life.
Need help rehoming your pet responsibly? Many local rescues and shelters offer guidance—even if you don’t surrender the animal. Don’t hesitate to reach out.
You can submit a Help Request form to us by visiting this link.
Your pet’s future depends on it.
Helping Outside Animals 